What if I told you I start my morning with a glass of lemon water?
Maybe youâd think:
âWho cares?! Why does it matter what Berardi drinks first thing in the morning?â
You wouldnât be wrong.
But if youâre a certain type of personâthe kind who loves to geek out on nutrition scienceâit might spark your curiosity (and maybe a little FOMO).
Perhaps youâd ask:
âWhy add lemon? For digestion? Liver detoxification? Antioxidant protection?â
In other words:
âDoes lemon contain some sort of biochemical superpower I havenât yet learned about? And, if so, should I be including it myself?â
If youâre another type of personâmore skeptical in natureâyou might be less curious and more annoyed:
âUghâmore detoxing BS?!? Detoxing isnât even a thing. I thought you were evidence-based!â
If youâre super up-to-date on the latest research, you might even say:
âLemons, really? Havenât you done your research? Donât you know that [enter nutrient/supplement du jour] has proven to be more effective?â
So, just in case youâre wondering, hereâs the real reason I drink lemon water in the morning:
I wake up thirsty. And I like the taste of lemon in my water.
(Cue anti-climactic music.)
Yep, thatâs it.
Thatâs the big secret behind my beverage choice.
Iâm not trying to support liver detoxification or digestion.
Nor am I trying to add antioxidant power or alter my bodyâs pH.
(Iâm also not an âindustry shill for Big Lemon.â Promise.)
I simply like the taste.
Now, if that answer disappoints youâor you were already halfway to the store to pick up some lemonsâyou might need to hear what Iâm about to say.
Because I think itâs time we stop over-nutritionalizing our food.
Before we go any further, I have to admit something.
Iâve been guilty of the very thing Iâm critiquing in this article. In fact, if you like, you can blame the whole problem on me.Â
Early in my career, I wrote A LOT, perhaps too much, about the biochemical and physiological properties of food.
I churned out article after article examining various signaling pathways in fat and muscle cells, and the specific nutrients that could alter them.
Now, I didnât intend to start a trend of over-focusing on the scientific properties of food. To be honest, I didnât really think much about my intention at all. (That was kinda the problem).
I was just really into biochemistry and physiology.
As a PhD candidate, publishers gave me a platform to share what I was learning, what I was experimenting with (in the lab), and what I found intriguing.
And when I co-founded Precision Nutrition, I was able to reach and influence even more people.
Along the way, readers took a cue from me.
Coaches, trainers, and fellow ânutrition nerdsâ fell down the rabbit hole too. They followed my interests. They started focusing on the biochemical and nutritional details of food. And, like me, they shared their interests, thoughts, and experiments with others.
It started a chain reaction.
Yet, as Precision Nutrition developed, my perspective changed.Â
My understanding of food broadened.
I came to believe (as I still do) that food is not merely fuel. That no single diet is universally superior. And that there are a lot more considerations to eating than âhow does nutrient X affect pathway Y in my body?â.
Donât get me wrong: Understanding the scientific properties of food is helpfulâto a point.
Thereâs a reason why PN teaches the science of nutrition in the Precision Nutrition Level 1 Nutrition Coaching Certification: because itâs useful to understand the âwhyâ behind nutrition recommendations before you start doling them out to clients.
But when I look around these days, I see a lot of people hyper-focused on the biochemical and physiological aspects of food.Â
Call it over-nutritionalizing, over-intellectualizing, or over-sciencing. Whatever name you give it, itâs characterized by an almost obsessive interest in the nutritional and physiological aspects of a given food.
And we need to tamp that down. Or, at least, balance it out.
People always ask me, âWhyâd you choose THAT food / ingredient / supplement?â
Sometimes, I share pictures of what I eat on Instagram.
Either a single meal or an entire day of meals.
People are always asking me how I eat so, occasionally, I oblige by sharing my own meals or what our family is eating.
But every time I do, the same thing happens: People send a barrage of questions, most of them having to do with the physiological or health value of a particular inclusion (or exclusion). I try to answer the queries, but frankly, itâs hard to keep up.

No matter how much explanation I provide, the questions keep coming. Hereâs a sampling from recent posts of various meals.
- Why do you add lemon to your water?
- Why donât you eat yams or brown rice or (my favorite starchy carb source)?
- Why donât you eat pineapple, watermelon, or (my favorite fruit)?
- Why donât you drink milk, eat cheese, or (my favorite dairy)?
- I see you eat sauerkraut. Why not kimchi?
- I see you use collagen protein. Why not whey?
- You take a vitamin or a protein supplement or a probiotic? Which brand? Which strain? For what benefit? But what about the research that says X or Y or Z?
You get the idea.
Hence my lemon water example from earlier. Every time I show a meal with a glass of water with lemon, people are deeply concerned with the âhealth valueâ of the lemon.
In essence, it feels like everything the nutritionist eats MUST have a scientific reason for its inclusion.
Folks seem disappointed or dissatisfied when I tell them I add it because I like the taste. Or itâs one of my favorite foods. Or itâs all I had available that day.
Similarly, if I donât include a particular food on a given day, like brown rice or mangoes or coffee, folks get really wrapped up in whether I think the missing food is somehow âbad for you.â
Heck, everything the nutritionist doesnât eat MUST ALSO have a scientific reason for its exclusion.
But hereâs the truth:
Not every food decision I make is grounded in science.
Sometimes I eat foods because I like them. (Shocking, I know.) Or because they make me feel good. Or because our children want me to share a particular food with them.
Likewise, I often avoid other foods that I donât like. Or that make me feel bad. (Yep, even the âhealthyâ ones.) Or that arenât easily accessible to me.
Hereâs an example I posted about recently.
Iâve learned, through the process of self-experimentation, that tomatoes and peppers seem to cause flare-ups in the osteoarthritis that bothers my knees.
So, most of the time, I avoid them.
Even though I like to eat them. Even though there isnât much data to suggest that nightshades like tomatoes and peppers are problematic. I minimize them in my diet because they make me feel bad.
Now, just because Iâve stopped eating themâŠ
Am I saying that tomatoes and peppers (or other nightshades) will affect everyone with osteoarthritis?
No.
Can I tell you for sure that itâs the biochemical properties of the tomatoes and peppers that affect me and not something else (like the placebo effect)?Â
No.
Am I suggesting that other people should stop eating tomatoes and peppers?Â
Definitely not.
They just donât work for me.
So, whatâs wrong with nerding out on nutrition?
Like I said, Iâm a science guy. Thereâs nothing wrong with knowing your facts.
But this hyper-nutritionalizing can be problematic in a few ways:
#1: Your âresearchâ may not be all that good.
Itâs time to get real about something.
Nutrition science is complicated, and relatively early in its evolution. This means thereâs a fair bit of research out there thatâs open to interpretation.
(And very few absolute hard and fast rules that apply to everybody.)
As a result, itâs not hard to find research that justifies our own preferences.
Imagine thisâŠ
Suppose I enjoy a glass of lemon water in the morning. So I think to myself, âHmm, maybe thereâs a health benefit to this. Letâs find out.â
So I visit PubMed (the worldâs largest index of biomedical research) and search for scientific studies that support the use of lemon water.
Or I Google something like: âhealth benefits of lemon water in the morning.â (Try it. Youâll get lots of results.)
Bingo. Now I can start spreading the news of the virtuous lemon waterâand give myself a pat on the back for enjoying my superior morning beverage.
See the problem here?Â
Weâre biased. This type of âresearchâ is often a desire to justify our preferences and natural inclinations through âevidence.â
Thatâs a dangerous practice, one that breeds self-justification and a certain kind of âevidence blindnessâ to research that doesnât support oneâs preferences.
It also signals the end of curiosity, which is at the heart of scientific inquiry.
And it happens all the time, even to smart people and good thinkers.
They let their personal preferences lead their information search, instead of legitimately trying to get to the bottom of what humans do know (or can know) about a particular subject. Then, once theyâve found the research that supports what they were going to do anyway, they proselytize it as âprovenâ or âevidence-based.â
But âknowledgeâ that was gained in this fashion is, at best, incomplete.
At worst, it isnât really knowledge at all.
#2: Food is more than its biochemical make-up. (And so are we.)
When we get hyper-focused on the science behind our food intake, we miss out on other benefits of eating, like:
- Cultural practices/traditions
- Enjoyment and pleasure
- Expressing hospitality or spending time with family and friends over a meal
- How they make us feel, physically or otherwise
Just as âhealthâ is more than ânot being sick,â food is more than just nutrients.
And, for that matter, humans are much more than our biochemical and physiological makeup.
Whether or not a food âworks for usâ in the context of our daily lives has to do with more than just research.
It also has to do with our goals, our preferences, our lifestyle, our cooking skills, our cultural background, our eating and living situation, our access to certain foods, our taste buds, our social determinants of health, and so much more.
Sure, there are some general nutritional basics that work for most of us, but that doesnât mean that someone is doing it wrong if they prefer regular whole oats to steel-cut oats.
#3: It breeds judgment and the moralization of foods.
In a recent Instagram post, I mentioned that Iâve been âzero alcoholâ for three years now and that I think itâs contributed, in small part, to some positive health outcomes, particularly around hormonal health.
This statement was interpreted as a win for those with a âclean eatingâ or âvirtuous healthâ or âwhy would you put that poison in your body?â mindset.
Many folks gave me a virtual pat on the back for this choiceâas in, âExactly! Alcohol is poison!â
Meanwhile, others took it as a personal affront. Like I was attacking their decision to drink.
But for me, not drinking isnât a moral decision. Or a tribal one. I personally abstain because avoiding alcohol seems to help with my autoimmune disease.
And, to be honest, I never enjoyed drinking that much anyway. (Alcohol makes me irritable and sleepy which, alone, is annoying and, in social settings, makes me want to go home.)
But just because I donât drink doesnât mean I search for all the info I can find about why alcohol is bad for everyone and then proselytize against it. I understand it serves different needs for different people. And that some of those, on balance, could be healthy⊠in the right context. (For examples, check out: Would I be healthier if I quit drinking?)
Bottom line: â â Iâm not anti-alcohol, nor am I pro-alcohol; I just made a decision that felt best for me. And my point here is this:
Someone elseâs food choicesâwhether scientifically supported or notâshouldnât send you into a tailspin.Â
Nor should your personal food choices be the basis for telling others what they should or shouldnât do, regardless of what your self-directed scan of the research tells you is ârightâ or âwrong.â
If you find yourself doing either, itâs time to back up and gain some perspective.
I canât recommend a âbest foodâ or a âbest diet,â but I can recommend this.
Try to stay open-minded.
Itâs up to you to find foods that you enjoy eating, and that help contribute to your goals, whatever they might be.
And if youâre a coach, itâs your job to help your clients find those foodsâand those goalsâfor themselves.
A healthy relationship with food doesnât require you to nitpick over every small decision or have a scientific justification for everything you choose.Â
In fact, once you understand the basics of how various nutrients work in the body, a healthy relationship with food might mean the exact opposite⊠broadening your perspective on eating beyond the âscientific benefits.â
Yes, it can take time and practice to understand what works best for you, your body, your family, and your lifestyle. And to enjoy those foods without overthinking them.
Thatâs the balance here.
To recognize that, at the beginning of your âhealthy eating journey,â you might actually need to spend more time learning about your food to help facilitate better, more thoughtful choices.
But then, at a certain point, you might need to step back and try to integrate that new knowledge into the context of your real life. To situate it within a broader, more robust framework for making eating decisions.
Because, if you go too far here, your ideas about food can end up mired in superstition or âsciencestition.â When that happens, itâs difficult to be objective. Difficult to stay curious and open-minded. Difficult to learn anything, for yourself or for your clients.
So thatâs your first experiment.
Back away from the research database. Make yourself a meal without overanalyzing it. And while youâre at it, pour yourself a glass of water. Lemon or no lemon? The choice is yours.
If youâre a coach, or you want to beâŠ
You can help people build sustainable nutrition and lifestyle habits that will significantly improve their physical and mental healthâwhile you make a great living doing what you love. We'll show you how.
If youâd like to learn more, consider the PN Level 1 Nutrition Coaching Certification. (You can enroll now at a big discount.)
Share